List Environments

Summary

List environments are environments that have list-like properties. They are implemented by the listenv package. The main features of a list environment are summarized in the below table:

Property	list environments	lists	environments
Number of elements, e.g. `length()`	yes	yes	yes
Named elements, e.g. `names()`, `x$a` and `x[["a"]]`	yes	yes	yes
Duplicated names	yes	yes
Element names are optional	yes	yes
Indexed elements, e.g. `x[[4]]`	yes	yes
Dimensions, e.g. `dim(x)`, `t(x)`, and `aperm(x, c(3,1,2))`	yes	yes
Names of dimensions, e.g. `dimnames(x)`	yes	yes
Indexing by dimensions, e.g. `x[[2, 4]]` and `x[[2, "D"]]`	yes	yes
Multi-element subsetting, e.g. `x[c("a", "c")]`, `x[-1]` and `x[2:1, , 3]`	yes	yes
Multi-element subsetting preserves element names	yes
Resizing, e.g. `length(x) <- 6`	yes	yes
Removing elements by assigning NULL, e.g. `x$c <- NULL` and `x[1:3] <- NULL`	yes	yes
Removing parts of dimensions by assigning NULL, e.g. `x[,2] <- NULL`	yes
Mutable, e.g. `y <- x; y$a <- 3; identical(y, x)`	yes		yes
Compatible* with `assign()`, `delayedAssign()`, `get()` and `exists()`	yes		yes

For example,

> x <- listenv(a = 1, b = 2, c = "hello")
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 3 elements (‘a’, ‘b’, ‘c’).
> length(x)
[1] 3
> names(x)
[1] "a" "b" "c"
> x$a
[1] 1
> x[[3]] <- toupper(x[[3]])
> x$c
[1] "HELLO"
> y <- x
> y$d <- y$a + y[["b"]]
> names(y)[2] <- "a"
> y$a
[1] 1
> y
A ‘listenv’ vector with 4 elements (‘a’, ‘a’, ‘c’, ‘d’).
> identical(y, x)
[1] TRUE
> for (ii in seq_along(x)) {
+     cat(sprintf("Element %d (%s): %s\n", ii, sQuote(names(x)[ii]), 
+         x[[ii]]))
+ }
Element 1 (‘a’): 1
Element 2 (‘a’): 2
Element 3 (‘c’): HELLO
Element 4 (‘d’): 3
> x[c(1, 3)] <- list(2, "Hello world!")
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 4 elements (‘a’, ‘a’, ‘c’, ‘d’).
> y <- as.list(x)
> str(y)
List of 4
 $ a: num 2
 $ a: num 2
 $ c: chr "Hello world!"
 $ d: num 3
> z <- as.listenv(y)
> z
A ‘listenv’ vector with 4 elements (‘a’, ‘a’, ‘c’, ‘d’).
> identical(z, x)
[1] FALSE
> all.equal(z, x)
[1] TRUE

Creating list environments

List environments are created similarly to lists but also similarly to environments. To create an empty list environment, use

> x <- listenv()
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 0 elements (unnamed).

This can later can be populated using named assignments,

> x$a <- 1
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 1 element (‘a’).

comparable to how both lists and environments work. Similarly to lists, they can also be populated using indices, e.g.

> x[[2]] <- 2
> x$c <- 3
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 3 elements (‘a’, ‘’, ‘c’).

Just as for lists, a list environment is expanded with NULL elements whenever a new element is added that is beyond the current length plus one, e.g.

> x[[5]] <- 5
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 5 elements (‘a’, ‘’, ‘c’, ‘’, ‘’).
> x[[4]]
NULL

As with lists, the above list environment can also be created from the start, e.g.

> x <- listenv(a = 1, 3, c = 4, NULL, 5)
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 5 elements (‘a’, ‘’, ‘c’, ‘’, ‘’).

As for lists, the length of a list environment can at any time be increased or decreased by assigning it a new length. If decreased, elements are dropped, e.g.

> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 5 elements (‘a’, ‘’, ‘c’, ‘’, ‘’).
> length(x) <- 2
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 2 elements (‘a’, ‘’).
> x[[1]]
[1] 1
> x[[2]]
[1] 3

If increased, new elements are populated with unnamed elements of NULL, e.g.

> length(x) <- 4
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 4 elements (‘a’, ‘’, ‘’, ‘’).
> x[[3]]
NULL
> x[[4]]
NULL

To allocate an “empty” list environment (with all NULL:s) of a given length, do

> x <- listenv()
> length(x) <- 4
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 4 elements (unnamed).

Note: Unfortunately, it is not possible to use x <- vector("listenv", length = 4); that construct is only supported for the basic data types.

Elements can be dropped by assigning NULL, e.g. to drop the first and third element of a list environment, do:

> x[c(1, 3)] <- NULL
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 2 elements (unnamed).

Iterating over elements

Iterating over elements by names

Analogously to lists and plain environments, it is possible to iterate over elements of list environments by the element names. For example,

> x <- listenv(a = 1, b = 2, c = 3)
> for (name in names(x)) {
+     cat(sprintf("Element %s: %s\n", sQuote(name), x[[name]]))
+ }
Element ‘a’: 1
Element ‘b’: 2
Element ‘c’: 3

Iterating over elements by indices

Analogously to lists, but contrary to plain environments, it is also possible to iterate over elements by their indices. For example,

> x <- listenv(a = 1, b = 2, c = 3)
> for (ii in seq_along(x)) {
+     cat(sprintf("Element %d: %s\n", ii, x[[ii]]))
+ }
Element 1: 1
Element 2: 2
Element 3: 3

Coercion to and from list environments

Coercing to lists and vectors

Coercing a list environment to a list:

> x <- listenv(a = 2, b = 3, c = "hello")
> x
A ‘listenv’ vector with 3 elements (‘a’, ‘b’, ‘c’).
> y <- as.list(x)
> str(y)
List of 3
 $ a: num 2
 $ b: num 3
 $ c: chr "hello"

Coercing a list to a list environment:

> z <- as.listenv(y)
> z
A ‘listenv’ vector with 3 elements (‘a’, ‘b’, ‘c’).
> identical(z, x)
[1] FALSE
> all.equal(z, x)
[1] TRUE

Unlisting:

> unlist(x)
      a       b       c 
    "2"     "3" "hello" 
> unlist(x[-3])
a b 
2 3 
> unlist(x[1:2], use.names = FALSE)
[1] 2 3

Multi-dimensional list environments

Analogously to lists, and contrary to plain environments, list environments can have dimensions with corresponding names. For example,

> x <- as.listenv(1:6)
> dim(x) <- c(2, 3)
> dimnames(x) <- list(c("a", "b"), c("A", "B", "C"))
> x
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 6 elements (unnamed) arranged in 2x3 rows (‘a’, ‘b’) and columns (‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’).

An easy way to quickly get an overview is to coerce to a list, e.g.

> as.list(x)
  A B C
a 1 3 5
b 2 4 6

Individual elements of a list environment can be accessed using standard subsetting syntax, e.g.

> x[["a", "B"]]
[1] 3
> x[[1, 2]]
[1] 3
> x[[1, "B"]]
[1] 3

We can assign individual elements similarly, e.g.

> x[["b", "B"]] <- -x[["b", "B"]]
> as.list(x)
  A B  C
a 1 3  5
b 2 -4 6

We can also assign multiple elements through dimensional subsetting, e.g.

> x[2, -1] <- 98:99
> as.list(x)
  A B  C 
a 1 3  5 
b 2 98 99
> x["a", c(1, 3)] <- list(97, "foo")
> as.list(x)
  A  B  C    
a 97 3  "foo"
b 2  98 99   
> x[] <- 1:6
> as.list(x)
  A B C
a 1 3 5
b 2 4 6

Concurrently with dimensional names it is possible to have names of the individual elements just as for list environments without dimensions. For example,

> names(x) <- letters[seq_along(x)]
> x
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 6 elements (‘a’, ‘b’, ‘c’, ..., ‘f’) arranged in 2x3 rows (‘a’, ‘b’) and columns (‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’).
> x[["a"]]
[1] 1
> x[["f"]]
[1] 6
> x[c("a", "f")]
A ‘listenv’ vector with 2 elements (‘a’, ‘f’).
> unlist(x)
a b c d e f 
1 2 3 4 5 6 
> as.list(x)
  A B C
a 1 3 5
b 2 4 6
attr(,"names")
[1] "a" "b" "c" "d" "e" "f"

Contrary to lists, element names are preserved also with multi-dimensional subsetting, e.g.

> x[1, 2]
A ‘listenv’ vector with 1 element (‘c’).
> x[1, 2, drop = FALSE]
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 1 element (‘c’) arranged in 1x1 rows (‘a’) and columns (‘B’).
> x[1:2, 2:1]
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 4 elements (‘c’, ‘d’, ‘a’, ‘b’) arranged in 2x2 rows (‘a’, ‘b’) and columns (‘B’, ‘A’).
> x[2, ]
A ‘listenv’ vector with 3 elements (‘b’, ‘d’, ‘f’).
> x[2, , drop = FALSE]
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 3 elements (‘b’, ‘d’, ‘f’) arranged in 1x3 rows (‘b’) and columns (‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’).
> x["b", -2, drop = FALSE]
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 2 elements (‘b’, ‘f’) arranged in 1x2 rows (‘b’) and columns (‘A’, ‘C’).

Note, whenever dimensions are set using dim(x) <- dims both the dimensional names and the element names are removed, e.g.

> dim(x) <- NULL
> names(x)
NULL

This behavior is by design, cf. help("dim", package="base").

To allocate an “empty” list environment array (with all NULL:s) of a given dimension, do

> x <- listenv()
> dim(x) <- c(2, 3)
> dimnames(x) <- list(c("a", "b"), c("A", "B", "C"))
> x
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 6 elements (unnamed) arranged in 2x3 rows (‘a’, ‘b’) and columns (‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’).

Rows and columns can be dropped by assigning NULL, e.g. to drop the first and third column of a list-environment matrix, do:

> x[, c(1, 3)] <- NULL
> x
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 2 elements (unnamed) arranged in 2x1 rows (‘a’, ‘b’) and columns (‘B’).

Important about environments

List environments are as their name suggests environments. Whenever working with environments in R, it is important to understand that environments are mutable whereas all other of the basic data types in R are immutable. For example, consider the following function that assigns zero to element a of object x:

> setA <- function(x) {
+     x$a <- 0
+     x
+ }

If we pass a regular list to this function,

> x <- list(a = 1)
> y <- setA(x)
> x$a
[1] 1
> y$a
[1] 0

we see that x is unaffected by the assignment. This is because lists are immutable in R. However, if we pass an environment instead,

> x <- new.env()
> x$a <- 1
> y <- setA(x)
> x$a
[1] 0
> y$a
[1] 0

we find that x was affected by the assignment. This is because environments are mutable in R. Since list environments inherits from environments, this also goes for them, e.g.

> x <- listenv(a = 1)
> y <- setA(x)
> x$a
[1] 0
> y$a
[1] 0

What is also important to understand is that it is not just the content of an environment that is mutable but also its attributes. For example,

> x <- listenv(a = 1)
> y <- x
> attr(y, "foo") <- "Hello!"
> attr(x, "foo")
[1] "Hello!"

More importantly, since dimensions and their names are also attributes, this also means they are mutable. For example,

> x <- as.listenv(1:6)
> dim(x) <- c(2, 3)
> x
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 6 elements (unnamed) arranged in 2x3 unnamed rows and columns.
> y <- x
> dim(y) <- c(3, 2)
> x
A ‘listenv’ matrix with 6 elements (unnamed) arranged in 3x2 unnamed rows and columns.

Henrik Bengtsson